Reviews policy

Every review is read before it appears.

Who can write a review, what we publish, and what a maker can and cannot do about it.

Who can review

  • Anyone with a MacProof account can review an app. One review per account, per app.
  • A maker cannot review their own app.
  • You can change your review later. A changed review is read again before it replaces the old one.

What "Bought it" means

A review carries a "Bought it" mark only when the email on the reviewer's account matches a purchase in the maker's payment records, which we read with the maker's read-only key. We do not show the email or the purchase to anyone. Reviews without the mark are still published and still count.

What we publish

A person at MacProof reads every review before it is public. We publish reviews that describe real use of the app, whether the verdict is good or bad. We do not publish a review that:

  • is not about the app, or says nothing a reader could use;
  • is abusive, or shares someone's private details;
  • is an advert, or was written in exchange for payment or a free licence without saying so;
  • comes from the maker, their team, or a competitor posing as a customer.

If we turn a review down, the writer sees the reason on their account and can rewrite it.

The rating

The star rating is the plain average of every published review. No review is weighted more than another, and nothing a maker pays for changes it.

What a maker cannot do

A maker cannot delete, hide, edit or reorder reviews, and cannot pay to have one removed. If a maker believes a review breaks these rules, they can write to us and we will read it again.

Report a review

Write to hello@macproof.com with the app and the review. We answer every report.

Last updated 20 November 2026. Questions: hello@macproof.com

The weekly MacProof letter

New indie Mac apps that passed our check, once a week. No ads from strangers, leave any time.

1 person here now 1,628 views since 19 Nov 2026